I am making the following suggestions for our party to consider before Gunther leaves the gathered adventurers [minus DeathStalker!] to go to the mayor's house on the South side of the Lake which is building #10 on our maps!
Some should consider going to the local village shop for supplies and possibly get some info from the local storekeeper and any customers.
Perhaps some should bunk down at The Golden Grain Inn and the others at the Slumbering Serpent Inn to possibly gather some info from the proprieters and any helpers or patrons at the inns.
Obviously a couple people need to go check on DeathStalker [see Shrill voice posting!]
My plan is for Gunther to go see Mayor Ormond and get some specific information with my map as to which buildings on the map are where people disappeared or left homes or stores abandoned for no apparent reason!
Mayor Ormond is an elected official and he of all people should know who exactly is missing and where they are missing from!
Also want Mayor Ormond to tell Gunther what the building #21 is over in the NorthEast corner of the map!
I think this information is imperative to learn before nightfall and to get back to one of the inns where we agree to have Gunther go to roundezvous with other members of the party!
Seems to me a night at the inn should develop into something more than just a place to get out of the rain to get some sleep!
A good place for a sneaky attack or a mysterious message to be delivered that gets things going including the inevitable fight against some evil thing(s)!
IMHO if we investigate these areas with groups of everyone in the party then every player gets involved and does not feel left out of the action while waiting on some other group to arrive with a report!
For the record I am perfectly content to continue travelling with Oriel, Sentinel and Fandil, but I am giving them the opportunity to choose to either go with Gunther or to go somewhere else with other characters in the party if they would rather!
Plus allowing for anyone else who wants to go with Gunther to meet Mayor Ormond to do so!