I grew up watching the original series as reruns and of course watched the Star Trek TNG, Voyager and DS9 series in the 80"s and 90's. The first reboot was exactly that; a reboot, and no-one gets greatness from a computer when it's re-initializing
Now that the characters have been re-introduced, however, the plot-line can begin to emerge, and Abrams does that with this movie, while also lining up the premise for future films (that five year mission, of course). Without giving away any spoilers, I enjoyed the tension between the characters, and Pine taking his own path on Kirk (defiant, courageous, finding his balance between rebel and Captain) is a pleasure to watch. Some people may find Quinto's take on Spock too much a departure, but I find Spock's human/Vulcan struggle interesting. Without it, the character could too easily be mistaken for Lt. Commander Data
The action was almost to fast to take in at a 3D viewing, but that may be these old eyes, and I am certainly likely to go again (and maybe again) to take in what I missed the first time.
My only disappointment? The 'new" science officer, who's name still escapes me. Really only served as a minor plot twist and eye candy for the male audience/Kirk. A rather gratuitous "almost nude but this is PG" scene felt contrived and was completely pointless (maybe the guys will disagree
).
Cumberbatch? Simply amazing...and I won't say anything more